top of page

German Carmakers Hit by China Sales Drop: Madox Square’s Paul Bennett in Reuters

Writer: Paul Bennett
Paul Bennett
6 days ago
3 min read

Updated: 4 days ago

Reuters quoted Paul Bennett, Managing Partner of Madox Square, in its report that German carmakers were hit by a sharp drop in China sales in the second quarter. Paul’s point was about pace: the German brands are playing catch-up while their competition moves faster. Third-quarter figures, published in October, show the gap has not closed.


What Reuters Reported

Volkswagen, Mercedes-Benz and BMW each saw China sales fall by at least 30% in the April to June quarter. Volkswagen had the steepest drop at 36.6%. Car sales in China as a whole fell for a ninth consecutive month in June, and a Volkswagen sales executive said the group could not escape a market decline of around 20%, despite initial momentum from newly launched, locally developed EVs.


BMW had already cut its 2026 guidance the month before, its third China-related profit warning in less than three years, citing fuel prices pushed up by the Middle East war. None of the three offset the China losses elsewhere. Global sales fell 8.6% at Volkswagen, 8% at Mercedes-Benz and 4.9% at BMW.


Why German Brands Are Struggling in China

Analysts told Reuters that German brands built their success in China on combustion heritage, which no longer resonates with young, tech-savvy Chinese buyers. BYD unseated Volkswagen as China’s top-selling carmaker in 2024, and by the end of 2025 Volkswagen had slipped to third place in China behind BYD and Geely Auto. Volkswagen briefly took the crown back at the start of 2026 on an EV-heavy product push, but Reuters attributed that respite to fading subsidies for greener cars.


BMW added that the war was hurting Chinese demand for the combustion models it still relies on there. Volkswagen, BMW and Mercedes are all updating their China line-ups with EVs tailored to the region. The question is whether they arrive fast enough.


“Running at Twice the Speed”

Paul told Reuters the German makers are trying to play catch-up “at a very rapid pace, whilst their competition is running at twice the speed”. On the Amazing EV podcast, he put numbers on it. Chinese model cycles run at 18 months to two years, against six or seven for legacy brands, and software-defined vehicles let Chinese makers skip the combustion era. China Shock 2.0 sets out why we see that gap as structural. Paul also noted that the Chinese profits that once subsidised German production costs have gone, which is why cost cuts and a smaller model range are on the table at Volkswagen.


Update: What the Third Quarter Showed

Volkswagen’s third-quarter deliveries fell 14.3%, its steepest drop in over four years, at 1.89 million vehicles, with China down 38.5% in the quarter and 30.2% over nine months. Its global battery electric deliveries slipped about 5%, even though Europe rose nearly 20%. BMW’s third-quarter deliveries fell 6.3%, with China down 24.8% to 114,355 vehicles while Europe rose 2.7%, the US 2.5% and group battery electric deliveries 7.2%. Mercedes-Benz Cars fell 8%. BMW said it held its own in Europe and the US, and it begins rolling out the Chinese version of the new iX3 in China in November. Volkswagen has also cut its 2026 operating margin guidance to no more than 1%, from a prior range of 4.0-5.5%.


What It Means for Europe, Lenders and Dealers

Reuters notes that falling car sales in China are pushing automakers towards export markets including Europe, and that applies to Chinese brands as much as German ones. Chinese brands took close to a quarter of UK new car sales in September, and UBS says Chinese vehicle exports to Europe are running nearly twice as fast as registrations. German makers are therefore losing volume in China and facing a more crowded home market at the same time. Europe is the relative bright spot in their figures, which makes it the market every rival now wants. What follows is our view.


Lenders and Lessors

Weaker volumes and profits at German brands raise the odds of pricing action, incentive spending and tactical registrations, all of which have fed through to residuals before. Residual assumptions on German-brand fleets should be tested against sustained price pressure from Chinese entrants, not only against the historic curve.


Dealers and Importers

Dealer groups carry the franchise mix. A franchise network built around German volume brands needs a plan for a market where those brands are fighting harder for share. The fifth R, remarketing, is where those pressures turn into numbers.


Talk to Paul Bennett

If you fund, lease or sell German-brand vehicles, how would sustained pressure from Chinese competitors change your residual assumptions? Connect with Paul on LinkedIn or speak to us.

bottom of page